Freeman

ARTICLE

Book Review: Antitrust and Monopoly: Anatomy of a Policy Failure by Dominick T. Armentano

JULY 01, 1982 by BRIAN SUMMERS

(John Wiley & Sons, 605 Third Ave., New York, N.Y. 10158), 1982 • 292 pages • $22.95 cloth, $12.95 paperback

This is an extensive revision of Professor Armentano’s classic 1972 study, The Myths of Antitrust. The cases have been updated and the arguments reinforced. A good book has been made even better.

All the major antitrust cases are carefully analyzed and thoroughly critiqued. The economic history of each case is given, along with the important court decisions. Most of these decisions, the author shows, penalized companies whose only crime was that they reduced costs, improved products, and thus served many willing customers.

But such competitive processes are ignored by the practitioners of antitrust. They view competition, not as a market process aimed at winning customer approval, but in terms of the size and number of firms in a given industry. On these grounds, it has been easy to convict firms which grew because consumers preferred their products.

If a company grows by efficiently serving the buying public, who is to complain? Frequently, complaints are led by the company’s rivals. Sometimes they attack the successful firm by filing antitrust suits.

Other rivals seek government franchises, certificates of public convenience, licenses, tariffs, price-sup-port programs, and similar barriers to entry. The companies that hide behind these legal barriers are the true monopolists, but they receive scant attention from those who claim to protect the consumer’s interests.

Since the publication of The Myths of Antitrust, several prominent authors have joined Professor Armentano in criticizing the efficacy of antitrust. But his books remain the only major studies which consistently view competition as a dynamic process, and oppose all antitrust on principle. Only through such principled, carefully reasoned opposition will the antitrust laws be repealed.

ASSOCIATED ISSUE

July 1982

comments powered by Disqus

CURRENT ISSUE

May 2013

From natural systems to human systems, we start to notice patterns in nature that are products of good flow. Adrian Bejan discusses this crucial insight--and how it makes freedom even more needful--in this month's interview. Zachary Caceres looks at what emergence can tell us about the universe, the market, the heart, and the sacred; Mike Reid recounts the tragedies produced when the State tries to impose its order on people who have already developed their own; Gary Galles channels Leonard Read: the State is a clenched fist, he says, so it cannot create; Brad Taylor says democracy might just be another imposed order in some situations; Karl Borden wonders whether an individual's right to be left alone can be part of the order of things; and much, much more.Download Free PDF

PAST ISSUES

SUBSCRIBE

RENEW YOUR SUBSCRIPTION

THE ARENA

The Arena is a monthly debate feature designed to help readers explore issues of concern to classical liberals/libertarians.

This month, the issue is Gay Marriage. The proposition is: Gay Marriage Expands Liberty. Richard Lorenc will be arguing for the proposition. Steve Esposito will be arguing against the proposition.

img E-mail Subscription

VIEW PRIVACY POLICY